Vintage Church web site

We have a logo but need to create a web site for a new church that is starting up in North Carolina. The church is hip, cool, and well ... Vintage.

Vintage Church

Tagline:
a timeless message for all generations

Desired Color Scheme:
Blue greyish-blue and yellow

Desired Style:
weathered look

Accepted File Formats:
Layered Formats (.psd or .tiff)

This is a new church that is starting up:

Here is our logo:
http://vintage.reimaginehosting.com/vintage.jpg
hi-res version:
http://tinyurl.com/2ozpaw

As an example, we like this site:
http://www.oakleafchurch.com/

We want to have similar navigation and buttons on the right.

Use the headings on that example site above for now. We'll change them after the we receive the design files.

We like the "weathered look" and would like to incorporate that in the site. The color scheme is that blue in vintage, along with the yellow ("a timeless message for all generations")

We're not going to fix the height of the design, like on the design above, so we need some kind of edge that can repeat vertically (which can be tough to do with the weathered look, but you're up to the challenge, right!?)

Get creative! Roll with it! Give me an excuse to use two exclamation points!!

Looking forward to see what you guys can come up with. Thanks ahead of time.